Lender’s technical advisor for water, wastewater and ZLD projects

Home Lender’s technical advisor for water, wastewater and ZLD projects

A lender’s technical advisor (LTA), also called the lender’s engineer or independent engineer, reviews a project for the banks or funds that finance it. The name varies by market and loan document; the role is the same. The questions are simple to state: can the plant be built for the budget and on the schedule in the financial model, and will it perform as the model assumes once it runs?

On water projects the answers turn on risks that general infrastructure reviews can pass over. The feed water differs from the design basis. Recovery falls short. The brine has no lawful, affordable endpoint. Membranes need replacing sooner than the budget allows. The salt that was meant to help pay for a zero liquid discharge (ZLD) plant has no buyer. Brine Consulting is an independent industrial water advisory firm in Amsterdam. We sell no treatment equipment, so in a lender review we have no technology or plant of our own to defend. We offer technical due diligence on desalination, industrial wastewater, water reuse, brine and ZLD projects for lenders and investors, either as the technical advisor or as the water specialist alongside a broader advisory team.

To scope a review for a specific financing, book a call or send us the project documents. Most pre-close work is a review of documents and data, which we run remotely wherever the project is.

Who does what on a financed water project

Role Works for Focus
Lender’s technical advisor (lender’s engineer, independent engineer) The lenders Technical feasibility, cost, schedule, contracts and the technical inputs to the financial model; then monitoring through construction and operation
Independent environmental and social consultant The lenders Under the Equator Principles, an independent review of the environmental and social assessment and management plans for all Category A and, as appropriate, Category B projects
Owner’s engineer The project sponsor Design review, procurement and site supervision on the owner’s behalf
EPC contractor and O&M operator The project company Building and running the plant to the guarantees in their contracts

The Equator Principles in force are the fourth edition (EP4), which signatory financial institutions had to implement by 1 October 2020 and which the Equator Principles website still lists as the latest version as of 4 November 2026 (EP4, Principle 7; about the Equator Principles). The environmental and social review can cover water use and water source, but it is not a process review. Whether the treatment train will actually deliver the guaranteed water, at the guaranteed cost, sits with the technical advisor.

In our view, whoever reviews the plant for the lenders should not also be designing it, selling it, operating it or advising the sponsor on it.

The water risks a general review can miss

In our view, these are the points where water, brine and ZLD projects are most likely to drift away from their financial models. The table sets out what we check for each.

Risk Where it hides What we check
Feed water is not what was designed for A design basis built on a few samples Sampling period and variability against the design envelope; internal consistency of the analyses (see our Water Analysis Validator and the guide chapter on variability, sampling and data quality)
Recovery falls short One headline recovery figure A stage-by-stage mass and water balance and the scaling limit at each stage (brine mass balance calculator)
No endpoint for brine or solids Disposal listed “by others” Permit status, receiving capacity, classification of solids and disposal cost over the life of the loan (evaluate the disposal endpoint first; brine disposal cost)
By-product revenue that never arrives Salt or mineral sales in the revenue case A named buyer, a product specification the plant can meet, and logistics (markets, offtake and logistics)
Membranes and consumables replaced sooner An optimistic life in the operating budget or a thin maintenance reserve Replacement intervals and prices against public benchmarks; our guide to industrial reverse osmosis system costs includes a 2025 municipal tender with five bids of about $553 to $1,353 per element
Energy cost Thermal concentration and high-pressure pumping Specific energy at design and turndown and the model’s sensitivity to energy price (sensitivity and uncertainty)
A performance test that proves little A short test, or one run on easier water than the design case Test duration and feed conditions, what is measured, and the link from a failed test to damages
Scale-up from limited testing Lab results presented as proof at full scale Pilot duration and how representative the pilot feed was (laboratory and pilot testing)

A public example: the independent engineer at Carlsbad

Lender-side technical reports are not normally public, but rating agency commentary sometimes shows what the independent engineer reported. In December 2013 Fitch Ratings affirmed the bonds financing the Carlsbad Desalination Project in California, a 54 million gallon per day seawater reverse osmosis plant then about 22% built (Fitch Ratings release, 13 December 2013, republished by Chemical Online). Its account shows the independent engineer at work during construction:

  • Progress and cost. The independent engineer, Black & Veatch, and the sponsor reported the project a few months ahead of schedule and within budget.

  • A design deviation. The design drawings showed a flocculation chamber of 726,000 gallons, 100,000 gallons short of the 826,000 gallons the EPC agreement required. The independent engineer said the impact was difficult to assess at that point; it and the sponsor said operational adjustments could help the plant meet its requirements.

  • Protection kept in place. The sponsor made its decision to proceed conditional on the contractors, KSD and IDE, confirming in writing that the resolution did not relieve them of their obligations under the EPC and O&M agreement. Failure to reach the guaranteed performance would trigger formula-driven damages of up to $60 million, supported by a parent-company guarantee and used to pay down part of the debt.

That is the job in miniature. A deviation is found early, its effect on performance is assessed honestly, including saying when it cannot yet be judged, and the lenders’ protection under the guarantees is confirmed in writing rather than assumed.

How the work runs

  1. Before financial close. A technical due diligence report on the design basis and its data, the technology and its references at similar scale and water quality, the EPC and O&M contracts (guarantees, test procedures, damages and exclusions), the capital, operating and replacement costs in the financial model, the schedule, and the permits for discharge and residues.

  2. During construction. Periodic monitoring, review of design changes against the guarantees, and the checks the loan documents require before funds are drawn.

  3. Testing and handover. Witnessing the performance tests and checking the results against the contract definition, not against a summary.

  4. Operation. Periodic review of output, quality, energy and chemical use, replacement spending and reserves against the model.

Site attendance during construction and at performance tests is agreed as part of each engagement. Where the lenders already have a general technical advisor, we can cover the water process, brine and ZLD questions as a specialist and report into that team. See also our advisory and due diligence and project management for environmental technologies services.

When a water specialist is worth adding

  • The technology is new at this scale or on this kind of water.

  • The project includes ZLD, brine concentration or salt recovery, especially if by-product sales appear in the revenue case.

  • The discharge or residue permit is not yet granted, or depends on limits that may tighten.

  • The EPC contractor or operator has few references on similar water.

  • The feasibility work rests on a short sampling campaign or lab tests only. Our post on zero liquid discharge feasibility studies sets out what a sound study contains.

Common questions about lender’s technical advisors

Who appoints the technical advisor? The lenders appoint it and it reports to them. How its fees are paid is set in the financing terms, so agree the scope early; the scope drives the fee.

Does the technical advisor approve the design? No. It reviews and reports. Responsibility for the design stays with the designer and the EPC contractor, and responsibility for meeting the guarantees stays with whoever signed them.

Do equity investors and acquirers need the same review? The technical questions are the same: will the plant perform, at what cost, and what happens if it does not. Our advisory and due diligence service covers technical due diligence for investors.

Talk to us about a water or ZLD financing

If you are assessing a desalination, wastewater, reuse, brine or ZLD project for financing or investment, a short call will show whether the water-specific risks are covered. Book a call about the financing or send the technical documents for a first read.

Written by the Brine Consulting advisory team. The Brine Consulting advisory practice includes Edwin Muller, a senior industrial water expert with more than 25 years of experience across refineries, petrochemicals, power generation, hydrogen, ammonia and critical industrial infrastructure, and Paolo Mattiuzza, Executive Advisor, Brine Management & ZLD Systems, with more than 20 years of international experience in environmental technologies, industrial water treatment and resource recovery. Meet our experts.

Questions about your site's water or brine?

Tell us briefly what you are working on and one of our experts will get back to you.