Zero liquid discharge (ZLD) at a mine means no water leaves the site as liquid. Everything dissolved in it, mostly salts, ends up as a solid that has to be stored or landfilled. It is rarely the default answer. In our view it makes sense when no outlet will accept the saline water, when the recovered water is valuable enough to pay for the plant, or when a regulator demands it outright, as some Chinese provinces do for coal mine water.
This page is for mine owners, environmental managers and study teams weighing ZLD against the alternatives. It uses two published mine water projects to show what high-recovery treatment really produces and what the final steps cost. We are Brine Consulting, an independent industrial water advisory firm in Amsterdam, and we sell no treatment equipment, so nothing we recommend depends on whether your mine ends up buying an evaporator, drilling an injection well or building no ZLD plant at all.
Why mine water is a harder ZLD case than factory effluent
Most ZLD experience comes from power plants, refineries and chemical sites, where the wastewater flow follows production. Mine water differs in five ways, and each one adds cost or risk before the plant makes its first tonne of salt.
The flow is set by geology and weather, not by the plant. Pit dewatering and groundwater inflow can run for decades, and a wet season can multiply the volume to be handled. A ZLD plant has no discharge valve, so storage for the wet years is part of the design.
Sulphate and calcium cap recovery. Many mine waters, especially from coal and sulphide ores, carry high sulphate alongside calcium. As reverse osmosis concentrates the water, calcium sulphate (gypsum) reaches saturation and scales the membranes. The usual answer is to remove it between stages, which adds reactors, clarifiers and sludge.
Acidity and metals come first. Acid mine drainage needs neutralisation and metal removal before any membrane will survive. Selenium, arsenic or uranium in the feed end up in the final salt and can make it much harder to classify and landfill.
Power and logistics are remote. Evaporators and crystallizers need large amounts of energy, and many mines run on their own generation.
The liability outlives the mine. Water can keep flowing after closure, long after the revenue that paid for the plant has stopped.
Salt, rather than metals, is often what blocks a discharge. In Pennsylvania, community groups appealed a permit amendment for a coal mine dewatering project that discharges to Dunkard Creek. They pointed to high total dissolved solids in the discharge and noted that the amendment was issued two months after a large fish, mussel and salamander kill in the creek (Environmental Protection, January 2010). Metals can be precipitated cheaply. Dissolved salt can only be diluted, moved somewhere else or turned into a solid.
Which mine waters end up as ZLD candidates
| Water | Typical issue | What it means for ZLD |
|---|---|---|
| Acid mine drainage | Low pH, iron, aluminium, sulphate, trace metals | Neutralise and precipitate first; the gypsum and metal sludge is often a bigger solids stream than the final salt |
| Neutral saline mine water (common in coal) | Sodium, chloride, sulphate, hardness | The classic high-recovery desalination case; gypsum scaling sets the recovery limit |
| Hypersaline groundwater or salt lake brine | Very high TDS, sometimes above seawater | Membranes reach their limit early; thermal steps or evaporation dominate the cost |
| Process water and tailings return | Reagents, thiosalts, cyanide, ammonia, nitrate | Usually recycled within the plant; treatment targets the reagent before the salt |
| Mineral refinery effluent (lithium, nickel, rare earths) | Sodium sulphate or chloride from the chemistry | Concentrated streams where a saleable salt is more realistic; see our page on lithium refinery wastewater and ZLD |
Size the solids before you size the plant
One line of arithmetic sets the scale of any mine water ZLD study: each megalitre a day at 1,000 mg/L of total dissolved solids carries one tonne of dissolved solids a day. A ZLD plant has to turn all of it into a solid, plus whatever lime and other reagents the treatment adds.
The eMalahleni Water Reclamation Plant in South Africa shows what that means at mine scale. It treats acidic, sulphate-rich water pumped from coal mines around eMalahleni (formerly Witbank) to drinking water quality. Figures from a 2009 International Mine Water Conference paper by Hutton and co-authors:
Capacity of 25 Ml/d, raised from a 20 Ml/d design during construction; commissioned in September 2007.
Average feed between September 2008 and February 2009: 3,727 mg/L TDS and 2,481 mg/L sulphate.
Three reverse osmosis stages at 60% to 65% recovery each, with precipitation reactors, hydrocyclones, clarifiers and ultrafiltration between them to drop out the calcium sulphate that the previous stage had supersaturated.
Overall water recovery stabilised at about 99.5%, against an original target of 97%. Liquid waste fell below 1% of the feed.
Clarifier sludge dewatered in filter presses: roughly 200 tons a day.
Run the arithmetic on those numbers. At 25 Ml/d and 3,727 mg/L, the plant takes in about 93 tonnes of dissolved solids a day. Lime and other reagents, plus the water still held in filter cake, help explain why the sludge figure is about twice the dissolved load. The recovered water is the product; the solids are the long-term problem.
What made the economics work was a buyer for the water. In 2015 Anglo American reported that the plant supplied 16 million litres a day to the eMalahleni Local Municipality, about 12% of its requirements, and that a second phase then under construction would raise capacity to 50 million litres a day (Anglo American, August 2015). Without that offtake, the same plant would have been a very expensive way to make sludge.
You can run the same balance on your own water with our free brine mass balance calculator. Check the analysis first with the Water Analysis Validator: if the ions do not balance, the sulphate and calcium figures that set your recovery limit may be wrong.
Why does the last cubic metre cost the most?
Each step recovers less water from a stronger brine, so the cost per tonne of water rises at every step and the final thermal stage costs many times more than the first membrane stage. A 2023 feasibility analysis of a coal mine in the southern Ordos Basin, China, puts numbers on that pattern (Du et al., Sustainability, 2023). The mine, referred to as H coal mine, produces 1,920 m³ an hour of water at 6,236 mg/L TDS: roughly 287 tonnes of dissolved solids a day by the rule above. The authors modelled four concentration steps and their direct operating cost per tonne of water each step recovers.
| Concentration step | Brine leaving the step | Operating cost per tonne of water recovered |
|---|---|---|
| Reverse osmosis 1 | 834.88 m³/h at 14,248 mg/L | CNY 12.58 |
| Reverse osmosis 2 | 481.04 m³/h at 24,533 mg/L | CNY 23.47 |
| Reverse osmosis 3 | 239.8 m³/h at 49,028 mg/L | CNY 58.69 |
| Mechanical vapour recompression | 120.6 m³/h at 88,250 mg/L | CNY 143.92 |
These are modelled costs from the paper, not measured plant results. The trend is the point: water recovered in the evaporator cost more than eleven times as much per tonne as water recovered in the first RO stage, and the 120.6 m³/h of brine left after it still needed a final destination.
The same paper shows why the policy setting matters. It notes that some Chinese provinces require zero discharge of coal mine water, that evaporation ponds there have been discontinued for policy reasons, and that the first zero-discharge mine water project in China was built at the Shenhuaning coal mine in 2017. It also prices the alternative it preferred: two RO stages, then deep geological storage of the remaining concentrate. Its estimates, again calculated rather than taken from a built plant, put the evaporation and crystallization route at about CNY 234 million in construction investment, against about CNY 65 million for the storage wells and monitoring. Salt sales barely register: the authors expected 250 tonnes a year of sodium chloride and 350 tonnes a year of sodium sulphate, worth about CNY 150,500 a year at their assumed prices, and warned that selling them is hard without a salt or alkali industry nearby.
Suppliers make the same point from their side. A DuPont case study (supplier-written) on CHN Energy’s coal chemical plant at Ningdong, Ningxia, says recovering up to 95% of the water with membranes before the thermal stage cut the cost of that thermal ZLD processing by up to 60% (DuPont, 2022).
In our view, the practical lesson is to decide where concentration should stop before deciding how to do it. Our guide chapters on evaluating the disposal endpoint first and when MLD is preferable set out the method, and our comparison of minimum liquid discharge and ZLD covers the cost gap in general terms.
Which option should a mine test first?
In our view, full ZLD is the right answer only once every cheaper outlet has been ruled out. The table gives our starting point for common situations; treat it as a screening aid, not a design rule.
| Your situation | Option to test first | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A licensed discharge exists and the receiving water can take the salt load | Treat to the licence limits and discharge | ZLD adds energy and solids with no compliance benefit |
| The site is short of water and the process tolerates brackish water | Partial treatment and reuse in processing or dust suppression | Cuts both the fresh water bought and the volume to treat |
| A town, power station or farm will pay for treated water | High-recovery desalination, as at eMalahleni | Water revenue carries the plant; the solids become the design problem |
| No discharge, but deep injection or storage is permitted | Concentrate with membranes, then inject the concentrate | Avoids the most expensive thermal steps |
| No discharge, no injection, ponds not allowed or full | Full ZLD with crystallization | The only remaining route; plan the landfill for mixed salts from day one |
| Water will keep flowing after closure | Treatment that can run cheaply for decades | Ask who pays for the plant once the mine stops earning |
Most real sites sit between two rows. A mine may discharge in the wet season and recycle in the dry, or run high-recovery membranes now and leave space for a crystallizer if the licence tightens. Our MLD vs ZLD screener gives a first read on which side of the line your site falls.
What to have on the table before choosing a treatment train
A site water balance for wet and dry years, including pit inflow, rainfall runoff, process demand and storage. Our industrial water balance tool is a starting point.
A full, consistent water analysis, with sulphate, calcium, barium, strontium, silica and the metals your regulator lists, sampled across seasons.
Every possible outlet and its limit: river, sewer, injection, evaporation, sale of water, sale of salt.
The value of recovered water to the mine and to anyone nearby who might buy it.
The solids tonnage and its destination, including whether any of it would be classed as hazardous.
Power availability and cost at the site.
The closure horizon: how long water will keep flowing and who will own the plant then.
If any of these is missing, a vendor’s ZLD proposal will be sized on an assumption. Our ZLD vendor proposal checklist lists what to check once offers arrive, and our guide to comparing ZLD consultants on cost and ROI covers what to ask an adviser.
Mine water by region
Regulators, climates and ore bodies change the answer. We cover them in separate pages:
Mine water treatment in Australia, with a focus on Western Australia and the Pilbara
Queensland mine water treatment and coal seam gas brine management
Mine water treatment in Chile and desalination for mining in Chile
Mine water treatment in Ontario and potash brine in Saskatchewan
Permits, ponds and salt sales
Does ZLD remove the need for a discharge licence? It removes the discharge, not the approvals. The plant, the brine and water storage, the residue landfill and any air emissions from evaporation still need permits, and a regulator will want to know what happens when a wet season exceeds the plant’s capacity.
Is an evaporation pond a form of ZLD? No liquid leaves, so some sites call it that. The salt stays in the pond, the pond grows, and at closure it becomes a landform that has to be capped or removed.
Can we sell the salt? Rarely in volume. Mine water salts are usually mixed sodium, calcium and magnesium sulphates and chlorides with traces of metals. A saleable product needs separation, a purity specification and a buyer within trucking distance. Refinery streams with one dominant salt are better candidates than pit water.
Is mine water ZLD only for coal? No, but coal mines and coal chemical plants supply most of the published examples, because their water is often both saline and voluminous. Metal mines more often face acidity and specific metals first and salt second.
Getting an independent read before the study is scoped
A ZLD study is only as good as the outlet, water balance and closure assumptions it starts from. If your mine has a saline surplus with no settled outlet, a licence change coming, or ZLD offers that do not compare like for like, we can review your water data, balance and licence conditions, remotely or through a defined engagement, and tell you which row of the option table above your site really sits in. Ask for a scoping call, share your mine water data or write to christos@brineconsulting.com. This work sits within our water treatment and ZLD consulting and brine resource recovery services.
Written by the Brine Consulting advisory team. The Brine Consulting advisory practice includes Paolo Mattiuzza, Executive Advisor for brine management and ZLD systems, with more than 20 years of international leadership experience in the environmental and industrial B2B sectors, and Dr. Christopher Fellows, Part Time Consultant, a senior water technology and physical chemistry expert with more than 30 years of combined academic and industrial research experience. Meet our experts.