Under the US steam electric effluent guidelines, a coal-fired plant that will keep burning coal beyond 2034 must stop discharging flue gas desulfurization (FGD) wastewater by a date its permitting authority sets, and no later than 31 December 2034. That deadline was 31 December 2029 until EPA’s Deadline Extensions Rule, published on 31 December 2025 and in force since 2 March 2026. The zero-discharge requirement itself did not change.
So the question for most plants is no longer whether, but which route and when. This page sets out the current rules as of 4 November 2026, what makes FGD purge one of the hardest industrial streams to take to zero, and how to match the route to the unit’s remaining life.
The rules today, and how they got here
| Date | Action | What it did for FGD wastewater |
|---|---|---|
| 3 Nov 2015 | 2015 final rule | First federal limits on toxic metals in power plant wastewater |
| 13 Oct 2020 | 2020 reconsideration rule | Revised FGD limits and technology basis, added subcategories and revised the voluntary incentives programme |
| 9 May 2024 | 2024 supplemental rule published (in force 8 July 2024) | Zero discharge of FGD wastewater for plants that keep burning coal, originally by 31 Dec 2029 |
| 31 Dec 2025 | Deadline Extensions Rule published (in force 2 Mar 2026; corrections published 30 Jan 2026) | Zero-discharge deadline moved to 31 Dec 2034; notice deadline for the 2034 retirement subcategory moved to 31 Dec 2031 |
| 18 May 2026 | Proposed rule on unmanaged combustion residual leachate | Covers leachate only; no change proposed to FGD wastewater |
EPA has said it is collecting information on the practical difficulties of the 2024 zero-discharge technologies to support a future rulemaking, while stating that the extension “does not change the zero-discharge requirements themselves” (EPA). Plan against the rule as written, and watch the docket.
Which requirement applies to your unit
The current text of 40 CFR 423.13(g) and 423.19 (eCFR, current as of October 2026) gives these main paths for direct dischargers:
| Unit situation | FGD requirement | Key dates |
|---|---|---|
| Keeps burning coal beyond 2034 | Zero discharge of FGD wastewater | Date set by the permit, no later than 31 Dec 2034. On request, permeate or distillate from a system designed for zero discharge may be discharged for up to one more year |
| Same unit, until zero discharge applies | 2020 limits: arsenic 18 µg/L daily maximum and 8 µg/L 30-day average; mercury 103 and 34 ng/L; selenium 70 and 29 µg/L; nitrate/nitrite as N 4 and 3 mg/L | Due no later than 31 Dec 2025 |
| Will stop burning coal by 31 Dec 2034 and has filed the notice | Keeps the limits already in its permit; no FGD discharge after 30 Apr 2035 | Notice due by 31 Dec 2031 |
| Certified to stop burning coal by 31 Dec 2028 | No FGD discharge after 30 Apr 2029 | Notice was due by 27 Jun 2023 |
| Unit of 50 MW or less, or oil-fired | Suspended solids limit only | No zero-discharge requirement |
| Joined the voluntary incentives programme | Tighter limits including TDS of 306 mg/L daily maximum and 149 mg/L 30-day average, and bromide of 0.2 mg/L | Limits by 31 Dec 2028; notice was due by 13 Oct 2021 |
Plants that send FGD wastewater to a municipal treatment plant fall under pretreatment standards with their own deadlines, which the 2025 rule also extended. This table is a planning summary, not legal advice; your permit and the regulation govern.
The practical point: a unit that will stop burning coal by the end of 2034 can file a notice by 31 December 2031 and avoid building ZLD at all. A unit that will run longer has about eight years, which shrinks quickly once pilot testing, permitting, procurement and commissioning are added, especially for membrane-led designs that EPA says have no full-scale US installation on FGD wastewater.
What EPA counts as zero-discharge technology
The 2024 rule names membrane filtration, spray dryer evaporators and thermal evaporation systems, alone or combined, as the technology basis, with chemical precipitation before them and crystallization after them as options. The recovered permeate or distillate is recycled to the plant as FGD or boiler make-up water (89 FR 40198, 9 May 2024). Other routes, such as fly ash fixation, direct encapsulation and evaporation ponds, are not excluded.
EPA’s own count, at the time of the 2024 rule, is a useful reality check:
As of 2024, 40 US coal plants with wet FGD manage their FGD wastewater to zero discharge, using evaporation ponds, recycling, ash fixation, thermal evaporation or spray dryer evaporators.
Of those, four run full-scale thermal systems and three run full-scale spray dryer evaporators.
For membrane filtration, EPA said there was still not a single full-scale US installation on FGD wastewater; at the time of the 2020 rule it had cited 12 installations abroad.
If a supplier proposes a membrane-led train, ask for operating data from those overseas plants on a purge similar to yours, and budget for a pilot.
Why FGD purge is so hard to take to zero
FGD purge is an acidic chloride brine dominated by calcium and magnesium, it carries the trace metals the limits target, and its make-up differs from one station to the next. A wet limestone scrubber concentrates whatever the coal and make-up water bring in. Sulfur leaves as gypsum, but chloride stays dissolved and builds up until the plant bleeds some liquor off. That bleed is the FGD wastewater, and its chemistry is set by the coal, the scrubber design, the make-up water and how the plant is run, so every station’s purge is different (GAI Consultants, 2016).
Published examples show how wide the range is. A 2008 article by an evaporator supplier gives chloride of 30,000 to 60,000 mg/L, pH 4.5 to 5.5 and liquor supersaturated with gypsum (POWER, 2008). A 2018 cost comparison by a ZLD supplier assumed a scrubber chloride limit of 10,000 ppm (Power Engineering, 2018). A 2019 pilot, reported by its technology supplier, treated purge at about 6,900 mg/L chloride (Saltworks). Three features make it difficult to evaporate to dryness:
The salts are calcium and magnesium chlorides. They are very soluble, so they are hard to crystallize and the dried product draws moisture from the air. That 2008 article recommended lime and soda ash softening upstream, so that the brine becomes mainly sodium chloride, which crystallizes readily.
Hot acidic chloride brine is corrosive. The same article points to palladium-alloyed titanium or high nickel-chromium-molybdenum alloys where calcium and magnesium chlorides are concentrated, and to super-duplex or super-austenitic steels once the brine is softened to sodium chloride.
The trace metals are what the limits target. Arsenic and selenium must be measured at low parts per billion in a high-TDS matrix, where EPA has observed that other elements can bias ICP-MS results (EPA). Treat pilot and performance-test data with that in mind. For selenium chemistry, see our guide to selenium removal.
What sets the size: a chloride balance
The purge flow is set by a simple balance: chloride in from the coal and make-up water, divided by the chloride concentration the scrubber is allowed to reach. That makes the scrubber’s chloride setpoint one of the main levers on ZLD size.
The worked example below uses the example plant from the 2018 cost comparison (750 MW, bituminous coal, 200 gpm of FGD wastewater) and the 10,000 ppm chloride limit the same article assumes. Pairing the two, and the rest of the arithmetic, is ours, with assumptions stated.
| Base case | Chloride setpoint doubled | |
|---|---|---|
| Scrubber chloride limit | 10,000 mg/L | 20,000 mg/L |
| Purge flow | 200 gpm (about 1,090 m³/day) | about 100 gpm (about 545 m³/day) |
| Chloride leaving the scrubber | about 10.9 tonnes/day | about 10.9 tonnes/day |
| Same chloride expressed as calcium chloride | about 17 tonnes/day | about 17 tonnes/day |
Assumptions: chloride input from coal and make-up is unchanged; all chloride leaves in the purge; the calcium chloride row is an equivalence to show scale, not a prediction of the salt product.
Two things follow:
Halving the purge roughly halves the evaporation duty, not the salt. Every tonne of chloride the coal brings in still has to leave as solid or be fixed in ash. Raising the setpoint only works if the absorber alloys, mist eliminators and gypsum quality can tolerate it, so check that first with the scrubber supplier.
The residue route drives operating cost. In the same 2018 comparison, written by a ZLD supplier, full ZLD with landfill disposal of the salts was put at $32.82 per 1,000 gallons, against $4.37 when the concentrate was mixed with fly ash; the article cites operating savings of $2.8 million for a 200 gpm plant run to match the fly ash available. Fly ash routes depend on the unit producing enough suitable ash for as long as the ZLD plant runs, which links the treatment choice to the unit’s retirement date.
You can run your own numbers in our Brine Mass Balance Calculator, and check which minerals scale first as the purge is concentrated with the Industrial Wastewater Scaling tool.
Which FGD ZLD route fits your unit?
The unit’s remaining coal life narrows the choice before any technology does. A unit that will stop burning coal by the end of 2034 can file a notice and avoid zero-discharge capital; for a long-life unit, the deciding question is usually whether suitable fly ash will be available for the plant’s whole life. The table is our view of where to start, not a recommendation for any specific plant.
| Situation | Route we would evaluate first | Main risk |
|---|---|---|
| Unit stops coal by end of 2034 | File the notice by 31 Dec 2031 and keep meeting the permit’s existing limits; avoid zero-discharge capital | Missing the notice deadline, or a change in retirement plans |
| Long-life unit, fly ash available and landfill permitted for it | Purge reduction, then brine concentration and fixation or encapsulation with ash | Ash supply and quality changing with coal and load |
| Long-life unit, no suitable ash | Softening, brine concentrator and crystallizer, or a spray dryer evaporator | Corrosion, hygroscopic salts, high energy and maintenance |
| Unit with existing evaporation ponds and land | Ponds, possibly with upstream concentration | Land, liner and closure obligations |
| Membrane-led proposal | Only after a pilot on your own purge | No full-scale US reference on FGD wastewater as of the 2024 rule |
Stations with wet cooling towers also have blowdown to manage, a less aggressive stream with its own sizing logic; see cooling tower blowdown ZLD.
Questions to settle before you ask for bids
Which regulatory path is the unit on, and has any required notice been filed?
How variable is the purge? Flow and chemistry should be logged across full load, part load and outages, because each station’s purge is unique and changes with coal and operation.
What chloride setpoint can the scrubber tolerate, and what would raising it save?
Where will the solids go, for how long, and is fly ash available for the plant’s whole life?
Are the low-level arsenic and selenium results reliable in this matrix?
What has been piloted? Because every station’s purge is different, we see a pilot on your own wastewater as the strongest protection behind a supplier’s performance guarantee. Our page on wastewater treatability studies and pilot testing explains what a useful pilot measures.
When the bids arrive, our ZLD vendor proposal checklist helps put them on one basis. For the thermal end of the train, see our guide to the ZLD evaporator and crystallizer.
Other FGD wastewater questions
Can we keep running the biological treatment we built for the 2020 limits? Until the zero-discharge date in your permit, the 2020 limits apply, so yes. After that date, a plant that keeps burning coal cannot discharge FGD wastewater, so the biological system can only stay useful as part of a train that ends in zero discharge.
Is FGD wastewater the same as cooling tower blowdown? No. Both are saline, but FGD purge is acidic, saturated with gypsum, much higher in chloride and carries the trace metals the rule targets. It needs its own treatment train.
Can bottom ash transport water be sent to the scrubber? The regulation anticipates it: bottom ash transport water used in the FGD scrubber is then treated as FGD wastewater, so it falls under the FGD requirement rather than disappearing.
Talk to us about your FGD wastewater
Our advice on FGD wastewater is independent: Brine Consulting is an industrial water advisory firm in Amsterdam and sells no treatment equipment. For an FGD team the first decision is whether the unit needs zero-discharge capital at all; if it does, the next ones are the chloride setpoint, the residue route and what to pilot. We work through those remotely from your purge data, scrubber operating limits, ash balance and permit, or in a defined scoping engagement, and we can then put competing zero-discharge offers on one basis. See our water treatment and ZLD consulting service.
If the unit will burn coal beyond 2034, book a scoping call, send us your project details or email a recent purge analysis to christos@brineconsulting.com.
Written by the Brine Consulting advisory team. The Brine Consulting advisory practice includes Edwin Muller, a senior industrial water expert with more than 25 years of experience across refineries, petrochemicals, power generation, hydrogen, ammonia and critical industrial infrastructure, and Paolo Mattiuzza, a senior brine management and ZLD specialist with more than 20 years of international experience in environmental technologies, industrial water treatment and resource recovery. Meet our experts.