Industrial water treatment companies: who does what, and when an independent consultant pays off

Home Industrial water treatment companies: who does what, and when an independent consultant pays off

“Industrial water treatment company” covers at least six different kinds of business. A chemical supplier, an equipment maker, a design-build contractor and an independent consultant can all answer the same enquiry, but each is paid for something different. That payment model shapes the advice you get.

This page sorts them out: what each type sells, what it is good at, where its advice tends to lean, and how to compare offers that rarely start from the same assumptions. Brine Consulting, an independent industrial water advisory firm in Amsterdam, is the last type on that list. We are paid for advice and sell no treatment equipment, so which supplier you hire makes no difference to our income. If you already hold offers that do not line up, a call is usually enough to tell whether they can be compared as they stand.

The six kinds of company behind the search results

Type of company What you buy How they earn Where they are strongest Where their advice can lean
Chemical treatment service company (for example Solenis or Hydrite) A chemical programme plus routine site visits and testing Volume of product supplied, usually on a running contract Day-to-day control of cooling, boiler and process water chemistry Toward solving problems with chemistry rather than with equipment or operating changes
Equipment manufacturer (OEM) (for example Parkson) A specific technology: clarifiers, filters, membranes, evaporators Equipment sale, spares and service Deep knowledge of its own product and reference plants Toward its own technology, even when another would fit the water better
Design-build or EPC contractor A complete plant at an agreed price and scope Margin on the delivered project Taking on construction and schedule risk in one contract Toward a scope it can price with confidence, with exclusions that move cost back to you
Build-own-operate or “water as a service” provider Treated water or treated effluent at a contracted rate Long-term service fees Removing capital spend from your balance sheet Toward long contracts and terms that are hard to exit
Analytical laboratory Sampling and certified analysis Per test Defensible data for permits and design Gives numbers, not decisions
Independent consultant or engineering firm Assessment, design basis, specifications, bid review, oversight Fees for time or a fixed scope Comparing technologies and suppliers on one baseline Does not build or guarantee the plant, so you still need a supplier

None of these models is wrong. The trouble starts when a site asks one type of company to do another type’s job, for example asking an equipment maker which technology to choose.

Which one to call first

Start from the decision in front of you, not from the company list.

  • Routine cooling tower, boiler or process water chemistry. A chemical service company is usually the right first call. Ask it to run its own water analysis before it recommends a programme.

  • A failing or undersized treatment step on a working plant. Talk to the original equipment maker first, since it knows the design limits. Bring in an independent review if the fix it proposes is a larger version of the same unit.

  • A new plant, a new discharge limit, a reuse target or zero liquid discharge. Get an independent assessment before inviting bids. At this stage the technology choice is still open, and every supplier you invite will propose the one it sells.

  • Two or more quotes that are hard to compare. This is where independent bid review earns its fee (see the example below).

  • A financed project or an acquisition. Lenders and investors often need technical due diligence from a party with no stake in the equipment order.

Why quotes for the same plant can be far apart: a real example

In 2018 the town of Newport, New Hampshire, asked two suppliers for firm prices on a ballasted flocculation system for its phosphorus removal upgrade. The engineers reviewing the bids, Stantec as subconsultant to Fuss & O’Neill, published their evaluation, and it shows how much a price comparison alone can hide (review memo, Newport NH).

  • The lower bid lost. Veolia/Kruger’s Actiflo came in at a 20-year present worth of $1,332,241. Evoqua’s Co-Mag came in at $1,587,907, about 16% higher. Co-Mag still won, 91 points to 87, under a scoring system the town had set out in its request for proposals: cost 50, technical experience 20, operational factors 15, technical support 10, exceptions 5.

  • Scope differed in the fine print. The Actiflo base price excluded the polymer make-up system and charged separately for an access platform ($47,363) and operator training ($14,400). Both were included in Co-Mag’s price. Actiflo later offered to add the polymer system at no cost, a reminder that exclusions are often negotiable once someone spots them.

  • Support differed by more than double. Actiflo offered 9 days of on-site instruction; Co-Mag offered 21.

  • Operators had a say. Plant staff noted that one design’s clarifiers need periodic offline cleaning and the other’s do not. Operational factors scored 15 to 9.

  • Evidence came from outside the proposals. The reviewers interviewed seven reference installations and both suppliers ran side-by-side pilot tests at the town’s plant on four occasions over 12 months.

In our view the same lesson applies to industrial plants. A fair comparison needs one written design basis, cost judged over the plant’s life rather than at purchase, scope gaps priced back in, and criteria agreed before the bids are opened.

What to give every company before you ask for a price

Most wide gaps between offers come from suppliers assuming different things about your water. Give all of them the same written basis.

  1. Flows, including normal, peak and minimum, and how often each occurs.

  2. A full water analysis, with measured variability rather than a single sample. Before you send it, check that it is internally consistent: in a complete analysis the positive and negative ions should roughly balance. Our free Water Analysis Validator calculates the charge-balance error and compares the ion sum with reported TDS, so gaps in the lab data show up before a supplier sizes equipment around them.

  3. The target, whether that is a discharge limit, a reuse quality, a recovery rate or zero liquid discharge.

  4. Utilities and site limits: available energy, footprint, operator time and hours of attendance.

  5. What happens to residues, including sludge, brine and salts, and who is responsible for disposing of them.

  6. How you will compare offers, stated in the request. Ask suppliers to itemise labour, chemicals, equipment and travel so their prices line up, as the Association of Water Technologies suggests.

For zero liquid discharge projects, our ZLD vendor proposal checklist goes further, with 12 checks and the red flags behind each. If you are buying a complete effluent treatment plant, see our independent guide to choosing an effluent treatment plant supplier.

Questions that show how a company will work with you

  • For a chemical programme: what quantities and costs of chemicals do you expect per year, what make-up and blowdown volumes, and what cycles of concentration will you run? The US EPA recommends asking exactly this and choosing a vendor that can reach high cycles while keeping chemical costs low (EPA WaterSense at Work, 2012). Its guidance notes that raising cycles from three to six cuts cooling tower make-up water by 20% and blowdown by 50%.

  • For equipment: what does the performance guarantee cover, on what feed water, over how long a test, and what is the remedy if the plant falls short?

  • For a contractor: what is excluded from the price, and which of those exclusions will you need anyway?

  • For anyone: can we speak to two customers with water similar to ours whose plants have run for at least a year? Did the supplier stay within the contract amount, and did it warn them before costs rose?

What does an independent consultant actually do?

An independent consultant works for the plant owner only and is paid for judgement, not for equipment. On a treatment project that usually means:

  • defining the design basis and checking the water data behind it

  • screening the technology options before any supplier is chosen

  • writing the technical part of the request for proposals

  • putting the offers on one baseline and pricing back scope gaps

  • reviewing guarantees, acceptance tests and contract terms

  • following the project through commissioning when needed

It does not replace the supplier. The plant still has to be designed in detail, built and guaranteed by someone who sells it. What the consultant adds is a check, before you sign, that the plant on offer is sized for your measured water and judged against the target you set.

Our own work sits at the saline end of this field: saline wastewater, brine management, minimal and zero liquid discharge, industrial water reuse and resource recovery from brine. Our expert network includes specialists in desalination membranes, crystallization, produced water and industrial wastewater process engineering. See our water treatment and ZLD consulting and advisory and due diligence services.

Plants in the Netherlands and across the EU we review directly; for plants in other regions the review runs remotely or under a defined engagement. Most reviews start from two documents: your water analysis and the offers you hold.

Before you hire anyone: three common questions

Is an independent consultant worth the fee on a small project? It depends on what is still undecided. If the technology is settled and you are replacing a like-for-like unit, a good supplier and a clear specification may be enough. If the technology, the treatment target or the residue route is still open, a few days of independent review is small next to the cost of a plant that does not fit your water. The fee itself depends mainly on how many offers or options need comparing, how complete your flow and analysis data are, and whether the work continues through contract award and commissioning.

Can a supplier’s free site survey do the same job? A supplier’s survey is useful and often thorough. It is still carried out by a company that hopes to sell you its solution, so treat it as one input rather than the decision.

We already have a chemical supplier. Do we need anyone else? Not for routine chemistry control. You may want a second opinion when chemical spend keeps rising, when you are planning reuse or a new discharge limit, or when the supplier’s answer to every problem is another product.

Talk to us before the first quote arrives

Send us the offers you have, or the scope you are about to put out to tender. On a call we will tell you whether the offers can be compared as they stand and what each one leaves out. Book the call, send your project details or email christos@brineconsulting.com.

Written by the Brine Consulting advisory team. The Brine Consulting advisory practice includes Dimitra Aravani, External Advisor, Industrial Wastewater & Water Reuse, a senior industrial wastewater and reuse consultant with more than a decade of experience delivering water efficiency, reuse, and resource recovery projects for industrial and municipal clients, and Dr. Christopher Fellows, Part Time Consultant, a senior water technology and physical chemistry expert with more than 30 years of combined academic and industrial research experience. Meet our experts.

Questions about your site's water or brine?

Tell us briefly what you are working on and one of our experts will get back to you.